JFI Abstracts

Home / JFI Journals / JFI Abstracts

Journal of Forensic Identification

JFI Article Abstracts from 1998-2019 are available to view here at this time

IAI members can view and search the entire articles by logging into the Member Area.
For information on submitting articles for publication in the JFI, please review the instructions for submitting your manuscript.
Articles are in reverse chronological order the most current year, volume, and issue are on the top of the list.
This page shows all article abstracts from 2018 to current.  Please click the buttons below to locate abstracts from 1998-2017. Earlier version of articles are available for sale in the IAI Store 

JFI Abstracts from 2019

Issue 3: October to December 2019

Letter to the Editor

Author(s): Laskowski, Gregrory Eric
Type: Letter to the Editor
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 397
Abstract: Re: Assessing Latent Print Proficiency Tests: Lofty Aims, Straightforward Samples, and the Implications of Nonexpert Performance. J. For. Ident. 2019, 69 (3), 281-296.

Testifying on Fingerprint Examinations in 2019

Author(s): Neumann, Cedric, Ph.D
Type: Commentary
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 405

The Fingerprint Disaster Victim Identification Toolkit: From Powder to Biometrics

Author(s): Tamisier, Laurent; Thiburce, Nicolas; Prat, Lionel; Malo, Marianne; Ledroit, Pierre
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 413
Abstract: For the past 25 years, the Disaster Victim Identification(DVI) Squad of the Institut de Recherche Criminelle de la Gendarmerie Nationale, the Forensic Laboratory of the French Gendarmerie, has been involved in more than 80 identification missions of various types including natural disasters, aircraft crashes, road traffic accidents, and terrorist attacks. Members of this DVI squad have sometimes operated in extreme conditions, forcing them to adapt their equipment. This technical note explores the use of a fingerprint disaster victim identification toolkit, which is a portable kit that was developed through years of experience by fingerprint experts. This toolkit not only allows the use of traditional techniques to produce postmortem records but also includes a biometric sensor with a specific interface, combined with a portable automated fingerprint identification system. This operational toolkit offers an all-in-one system, devoted to disaster victim identification.

Using Gun Blue to Enhance Fingermark Ridge Detail on Ballistic Brass

Author(s): Christofidis, George; Morrissey, Joanne; Birkett, Jason W.
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 431
Abstract: Brass cartridge cases are the most common type of cartridge case found at crime scenes, but it is not always feasible to obtain identifiable fingermarks on these cartridges. This study evaluates the effectiveness of gun blue as an enhancement method on fingermarks that were deposited on brass metal discs and left to age (2, 7, 14, and 30 days) under different environmental conditions, namely, under dark conditions, under ambient light, and outdoors. Ten different donors (5 males, 5 females) were employed for this study, and their fingermarks (60 per donor) were enhanced with gun blue solution (50% v/v). It was possible to enhance aged fingermarks (natural and groomed) that had been deposited on the brass metal discs to an identifiable level, with the fingermarks left outdoors being the most challenging to enhance. The feasibility of enhancing fingermarks on fired brass cartridges shot from different firearms was also assessed. Despite favorable results being achieved on fired brass cartridge cases, more research is required to assess whether reliable enhancement can be achieved on fired cartridge cases under real crime scene conditions.

How to Fingerprint a Nearly 300-Year-Old Mummy

Author(s): Urbanová, Petra; Jurda,Mikolá; Králík, Miroslav; Ostrý, Ctibor; Vacht, Petr
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 451
Abstract: Obtaining postmortem fingerprints from a mummified human corpse represents a challenging task. Mummification alters, often irreversibly, elasticity of the skin. It dries, hardens, and creases the body surface to a degree, making it very difficult to employ conventional fingerprinting techniques. The present paper introduces a contactless three-dimensional digital approach for re-establishing a crease-free skin surface and for acquiring a two-dimensional reproduction of the volar surface of a finger pad. The technique was developed while fingerprinting Baron Franz von der Trenck (17111749),an elite Austrian-Hungarian military officer, whose naturally mummified body rests in the Capuchin Crypt in Brno, Czech Republic. His disarticulated left thumb was documented using an Atos Capsule three-dimensional scanner and close-range photogrammetry. In order to obtain a flat two-dimensional thumbprint, two techniques were proposed. One was based on digitally painted texture, which adheres on the ridges, but avoids the furrows. The other printed an enlarged physical replica of the volar surface built by employing PolyJet three-dimensional print technology. Both techniques successfully dealt with the rigidity and extensive wrinkling of the printed skin. The texture paint technique, however, depicted the skin characteristics uniformly and more clearly. The present case study lays down a foundation for incorporating an advanced three-dimensional virtual approach into fingerprint processing in the forensic context.

Processing Stamp Bags for Latent Prints: Impact of Rubric Selection and Gray-Scaling on Experimental Results

Author(s): Barnes, B.; Clark, J.; Kadane, J.; Priestley, M.; Tator, D.; Wauthier, D.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 469
Abstract: We report data on two open issues in our previous experimentation seeking an effective method for development of latent prints on glassine drug bags: (1) the choice of rubric to assess the quality of fingerprints and (2) the choice of whether to use color or gray-scale images. Two research projects were performed to evaluate the impact of the rubric choice and the color adjustments applied. The Dove rubric is preferable to the modified rubric previously used. Analysts report a more uniform application and a more thorough analysis resulting in an upward trend in scores. Although gray-scaling in experimentation is necessary to conceal which treatment was employed, native color images are preferable for casework. The results of this research quantitatively show the impact of native color as measured by the Dove rubric.

Lifting, Enhancing, and Preserving Blood and Other Proteinaceous Impressions Using Zar-Pro Fluorescent Lifters

Author(s): Zarate, Jessica; Muse III, Wilson; Nasser-Beydoun, Nadeane; Jones, Nathan; Barta, Jodi Lynn
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 487
Abstract: Zar-Pro Fluorescent Blood Lifters have been successful in lifting, enhancing, and preserving blood impressions; however, this technology had not been explored to determine their effectiveness in the recovery of nonblood proteinaceous impressions. This research project focused on optimizing the detection, enhancement, and preservation of impressions deposited in blood, semen, saliva, an eccrine sweat and sebaceous material mixture, and nonhuman oil using Zar-Pro Fluorescent Lifters.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 4, Page 524
Abstract: Funny finds from all over in their own words.

Issue 3: July to September 2019

Letter to the Editor

Author(s): Hockey, Daniel; Wilkinson, Della
Type: Letter to the Editor
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 241
Abstract: Re: Review of Several False Positive Error Rate Estimates for Latent Fingerprint Examination Proposed Based on the 2014 Miami-Dade Police Department Study. J. For. Ident. 2019, 69 (1), 5981.

Natural Fingerprint Development on an Unfired Cartridge Case

Author(s): Dove, Aaron
Type: Case Report
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 251
Abstract: This case report presents an operational file where the author was able to recover identifiable friction ridge impressions through nothing other than a visual examination. This case demonstrates how even the most difficult of substrates can sometimes produce usable evidence, while also emphasizing the importance of performing a thorough visual examination prior to utilizing any friction ridge development techniques.

A Case of Identical Latent Print Depositions

Author(s): Craven, Nicolas
Type: Case Report
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 261
Abstract: In December 2015, the Idaho State Police Forensic Services received a drug case for latent print processing. Following processing, latent prints were marked and forwarded for comparison. At comparison, two latent prints were thought to be the same latent impression inadvertently marked two separate times by the processing analyst. A review of the photos and the item itself revealed that the two latent prints were not the same impression, but rather two separate depositions with identical ridge detail, deposition pressure, and background noise. This paper discusses these two latent prints, how they could have been deposited, and where else in the literature similar or identical latent depositions have been addressed.

Fingerprinting Different Food Surfaces at Crime Scenes

Author(s): Brown, Jalessa; Clutter, Susan
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 271
Abstract: Latent fingerprints were placed on various food surfaces, which were then processed using powders, cyanoacrylate, and ninhydrin. The results of this study indicated that latents on four food surface types were best visualized using powders. Ninhydrin and cyanoacrylate were largely unsuccessful on food surfaces.

Assessing Latent Print Proficiency Tests: Lofty Aims, Straightforward Samples, and the Implications of Nonexpert Performance

Author(s): Max, Brendan; Cavise, Joseph; Gutierrez, Richard E.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 281
Abstract: Proficiency testing has long played a prominent and multifaceted role for the discipline of latent print comparison. Practitioners rely on proficiency testing results when making claims about the overall reliability of the field, as well as when making individual assertions of competency. In fact, in the case of unaccredited laboratories employing uncertified examiners, such testing may ultimately amount to the only objective evidence of competence that judges can consider. Additionally, proficiency testing plays a critical role in laboratory quality assurance programs, where results theoretically can be used to identify gaps in knowledge and training, as well as to supply roadmaps for improvement. But despite these vital functions, there is surprisingly little critical research or analysis by those within the discipline as to whether the current proficiency testing regime is effective and fit for purpose. And what little analysis does exist, mostly from sources external to the latent print comparison community, raises questions about the sufficiency of current tests. In order to more thoroughly investigate the rigor of current latent print proficiency testing, the authors (three assistant public defenders) participated in the Collaborative Testing Services Test No. 18-5161 and completed the test without committing any false positive errors. What follows is a discussion of that participation and its implications. The authors' hope is that the results spark concern about, and reforms to, the current proficiency testing practices in the United States.

The Capability of Forensic Vacuum Metal Deposition for Developing Latent Fingermarks on Fired Ammunition: A Preliminary Study Comparing Alternative Metal Processes

Author(s): Brewer, Eleigh R.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 299
Abstract: This paper examines whether vacuum metal deposition (VMD) is a viable technique for developing latent ridge detail from fired rifle and shotgun cartridge casings using six metal processes: gold zinc, silver, silver zinc, sterling silver, aluminum, and copper zinc. Each metal process was challenged with developing natural (unspiked) and sebaceous (spiked) deposits. The samples were left for different aging periods, from deposition of fingermark to firing. All samples were processed by VMD within 24 hours of firing. The viability of each metal process was evaluated by determining the number of samples having high-quality ridge detail developed, assessed using a grading scheme. Ridge detail was successfully developed on all fired cartridge samples. When considering both types of deposit on rifle cartridges, silver VMD was the most successful process overall, visualizing 80% of total fingermarks deposited to identifiable quality. For the shotgun cartridges as a whole exhibit, gold zinc was found to be the most effective process, visualizing 75% of total deposited marks (both natural and sebaceous combined) to identifiable quality. The results of this study are indicative of which VMD metal processes offer potential in developing ridge detail on fired cartridges.

The Use of Liquid Latex as a Pretreatment to Remove Debris off the Exterior Surface of Vehicles for Fingerprint Recovery

Author(s): Ho, Michael; George, Mathew
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 329
Abstract: This study tested the feasibility of using liquid latex as a pretreatment to recover fingerprints from the exterior surface of vehicles. The trials using the liquid latex pretreatment method recov-ered 177 of 270 fingerprints (65.5%). The trials with no pretreatment recovered 36 of 270 fingerprints (13.3%). Chi-square tests determined that there is a significant difference in performance between the liquid latex pretreatment method and the absence of the pretreatment method ( p=<0.05). An odds ratio test determined that the use of the liquid latex pretreatment increases the odds of fingerprint recovery by 12.3 times. The results indicate that the liquid latex pretreatment is a feasi-ble method of fingerprint recovery on the exterior surface of vehicles.

Stature Estimation from Palmprints in an Idaho Sample

Author(s): Craven, Nicolas
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 339
Abstract: Latent prints, including palmprints, may contain biological characteristics that may be used to generate investigative leads. Stature is one such biological characteristic. This study built linear regression models to estimate stature using three palmprint measurements from an Idaho sample. The sample consisted of 100 volunteers (48 males and 52 females) ranging in age from 21 to 73 years old. Overall palmprint length yielded the lowest confidence interval and appears to be effective for operational use.

Separation of Overlapping Fingerprints in Multilayered Carrier Using Optical Coherence Tomography

Author(s): Zhang, Ning; Wang, Chengming; Li, Zhigang; Wang, Guiqiang; Yan, Yuwen.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 355
Abstract: Fingerprints lifted from crime scenes are often overlapped because of multiple impressions of fingers. Current methods to separate overlapping fingerprints are primarily based on algorithms that estimate the orientation field of component prints. However, these methods need human intervention, and the accuracy of the separation may easily be degraded. In this paper, a novel tomographic imaging technique, optical coherence tomography (OCT), was used to separate overlapping fingerprints intuitively and noninvasively. The OCT system was also applied to reveal a hidden blood fingerprint that was completely covered by one layer of nontransparent paint. An additional experiment was conducted using a piece of fabric and fingerprints on tape to simulate a more realistic case work condition. OCT directly probed the internal features and extracted the images of component fingerprints deposited on multiple layers of material by three-dimensional volumetric imaging in a simple, intuitive, and easy-to-operate manner.

Investigating the Sensitivity of Cadaver-Detection Dogs to Aged, Diluted Decomposition Fluid

Author(s): Buis, Rebecca C.; Rust, LaTara; Nizio, Katie D.; Rai, Tapan; Stuart, Barbara H.; Forbe, Shari L.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 367
Abstract: Cadaver-detection dogs (also known as human remains detection dogs) are used worldwide to locate deceased victims and human remains. Ethical restrictions often prevent the dog handlers from using cadavers as training aids, resulting in a reliance on pseudoscents or human tissues, such as blood, bone, and decomposition fluid. Often these aids must be re-used many times because of the difficulty in obtaining new materials. The aim of this study was to investigate the dogs'sensitivity to aged human decomposition fluid samples that are used as a training aid. Human decomposition fluid was collected and serially diluted to 1 part-per-trillion (10-12) and aged up to two years. The samples were presented throughout the aging process to three police accredited cadaver-detection dog teams under standard indoor training conditions. The dogs were capable of detecting the oldest and lowest dilution levels of decomposition fluid samples. Ongoing training to retain this level of sensitivity is recommended. The results of these trials indicate human decomposition fluid is a valid training aid for cadaver-detection dogs.

Drone-Assisted Thermal Imaging to Determine the Location of Unmarked Graves

Author(s): Bodnar, Sara R.; Ciotti, James; Soroka, Justin; Larsen, Ray A.; Sprague, Jon E.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 378
Abstract: To test the potential use of infrared (IR) cameras mounted on drones during missing persons investigations, four deceased pigs were either left on the grounds surface or buried at depths of 6, 12, or 24. Flights were conducted on Days 1, 6, 12, 15, 29, and 57, with images taken at heights of 10, 25, 50, and 100. Images were then viewed to determine whether the locations of the pigs could be discerned based on temperatures recorded by the IR camera. Here, we demonstrate that putative gravesites could be predicted with a drone-mounted IR camera for follow-up physical investigation. Flights taking place from Day 6 to
Day 29 were most effective for identifying areas of interest when the pig was sitting on the soils surface or buried at 6. Imaging from altitudes of 50 and 100 were most efficient, allowing surveillance of a larger area per time, while retaining sufficient sensitivity for detection. The use of an IR camera attached to an unmanned aerial vehicle may be viable for the identification of sites warranting further investigation. The analysis of samples collected from the remains of the surface pig revealed the presence of gram-negative bacteria commonly associated with the mammalian digestive system, as well as organisms commonly associated with soil, suggesting that the metabolism of both indigenous and introduced bacteria contributed to the heat signatures that were detected.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 3, Page 394
Abstract: Funny finds from all over in their own words.

Issue 2: April to June 2019

Errors in Latent Print Casework Found in Technical Reviews

Author(s): Montooth, Marcus S.
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 125
Abstract: A variety of errors that were corrected through 100% technical review prior to cases being released were documented over a three-year period for 10 examiners at four laboratories within one laboratory system. Trends in cases, individuals, and the unit were revealed from the data. The number of documented errors makes it clear that 100% technical review and the verification process are essential portions of the latent print examination process.

Development of Latent Fingerprints on Thermal Paper by Immersion in Hot Water

Author(s): Jonas, Albert; Rubner, Isabel; Oetken, Marco
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 141
Abstract: This proof-of-concept study presents a new method of making latent fingerprints visible on thermal paper by briefly immersing them in hot tap water. When this technique is used, a dark positive impression appears while the paper remains white and the imprint is preserved. Various factors, such as the influence of time since deposition and the persistence of the developed impression, were investigated. Optimal results were achieved with fresh to several hours old fingerprints. For impressions that were several weeks old, this method was not sufficiently reliable. The brightness and contrast of the developed fingerprints changed within the first week after development. The contrast of faded impressions could be increased in 75% of the samples by re-immersion in hot water. On low-sensitivity thermal papers, such as parking tickets, no fingerprints could be developed that would be sufficient for identification. Additionally, because of the need to pretest a portion of the specimen to determine the adequate developmental temperature by cutting off small paper samples, further research is needed to avoid this damaging of the evidence.

The Influence of Hematocrit Value on Area of Origin Estimations for Blood Source in Bloodstain Pattern Analysis

Author(s): Aplin, S.; Reynolds, M.; Mead, R.J.; Speers, S.J.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 163
Abstract: The ability to reconstruct a bloodstain impact pattern to determine the source of bloodshed events is invaluable in forensic investigations. However, the effect that viscosity has on this process essentially remains an unknown variable. This research aimed to determine whether the viscosity of a contributing blood source, as dictated by the hematocrit (Hct) value, affects the accuracy of area of origin (AOO) determination when employing the tangent method for reconstruction. Six Hct values between 8% and 90% (n=8 replicates) were employed for analysis, and the differences between the known and calculated AOO were statistically compared using parametric multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and nonparametric nonmetric multidimensional scaling analysis (NMDS). The results found that varying the Hct of a contributing blood source had no effect on the accuracy of the AOO calculations, with all impact patterns generating three-dimensional coordinates within the industry-acceptable error margin. Because of the added scientific data, these results will provide support in the presentation of bloodstain reconstruction evidence in a court of law.

Pattern Type Frequencies in Middle Eastern Populations

Author(s): Bair, Bethany R.; Talebian, Kelly C.
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 176
Abstract: Although overall pattern types or Level 1 detail in friction ridge skin cannot be used to effect an identification, it can be used to group prints. Past studies have been conducted on overall Level 1 information that provided the fingerprint discipline with statistics on the frequency of pattern types within different ethnic populations. Overall pattern frequencies are often reported at approximately 5% for arches, 60 to 65% for loops, and 30 to 35% for whorls. Research that was focused on different ethnic populations has shown that these pattern frequencies can vary significantly by group.
Studies of pattern type distributions among Middle Eastern populations have been limited up to this time. This current study examined 100 known recordings of Iraqi prints and 100 known recordings of Afghani prints to see whether these frequency statistics varied from those of other published populations. Analysis of the combined Iraqi and Afghani datasets determined that arches appear with a frequency of 3.5%, loops at 52.3%, and whorls at 42.9%. Whorls within the Iraqi and Afghani dataset are seen at a significantly higher rate than the commonly reported values for overall pattern frequency. Additionally, the Afghani data showed whorl patterns occur at essentially equal frequencies as the loop pattern types. In most previously studied populations, loop patterns were found to predominate over whorl patterns. These datasets were intercompared with the Spanish population datasets previously published by Gutierrez et al. Individual finger pattern frequencies were also examined, with many instances of significant differences noted between the Spanish, Afghani, and Iraqi populations

Distinguishing Forged and Fabricated Prints

Author(s): Barton, Kimberlee; Matthias, Gregory
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 195
Abstract: A study was performed to determine whether analysts could distinguish between true latent prints and forged or fabricated prints. Eighteen prints were created (10 true, 4 forged, and 4 fabricated) and the study was broken up into two parts. Part 1 of this study followed the normal latent print examination of comparing the prints to known inked standards. In Part 2, the participants were asked to indicate whether they believed the print was a legitimate latent print or whether it was forged or fabricated. When presented with the option of a forgery or fabricated print, no analyst was perfect in the analysis of 18 prints.

The Effect of Ignitable Liquid Analysis on Latent Fingermark Development

Author(s): Avissar, Yaniv Y.; Hefetz, Ido; Grafit, Arnon; Kimchi, Sarit; Muller, Dan
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 207
Abstract: Improvised incendiary devices, such as petrol bombs (Molotov cocktails), are used by criminals, protestors, and terrorists. Forensic scientists face the dual challenges of identifying the liquid fuel to prove criminal intent (arson) and recovering latent fingermarks that may lead to a suspect.
This research examines the potential impact of fire debris analysis on fingermark quality, so that the forensic sequential examination of arson debris analysis and fingermarks can be better understood.
Our experiment revealed that latent fingermarks deposited on glass, exposed to gasoline, and developed by black magnetic powder were of poorer quality than those exposed to kerosene and diesel fuel. The effect of temperature on gasoline was also investigated. A primary conclusion is that the temperature and the concentration of gasoline influenced the quality of developed latent fingermarks.

Estimation of Stature by Measuring Dimensions of the Main Part of Foot Outline

Author(s): Kafi, Khadidja; Pacha, Adda Ali; Said, Naima Hadj
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 222
Abstract: The present study evaluates a possible correlation between stature and seven dimensions taken from the main part of the foot. To establish a regression model for estimating the stature from this part of a foot, a computer database was constructed, using measurements from pictures of the feet of 102 Algerian volunteers (85 men and 17 women).
It was found that the seven parameters showed a positive correlation with the stature but at different degrees ( p<0.001). The diagonal lengths (D1 and D2) and the parallel lengths (DP1and DP2) had higher correlation coefficients than the breadth at the ball and the breadth at the heel, with a higher coefficient of determination and a lower standard error of the estimate. The parallel length DP1 showed the highest correlation coefficient (r=0.7598).

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy CLPE
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 2, Page 238
Abstract: The medial joints from these two brothers are a true QUIP. They are unusual patterns that are not seen very often in the distal joints, which have a more wavy or straight appearance. The interesting part is the flow of the pattern is opposite of what is common in the distal joint..

Issue 1: January-March 2019

Letter to the Editor

Author(s): Hoerricks, Jim
Type: Letter to the Editor
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 001
Abstract: Re: Lack of Enforcement of Standards as Regards the Testing of Human Subjects

Letter to the Editor

Author(s): Hoerricks, Jim
Type: Letter to the Editor
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 005
Abstract: Re: Meline, K. A.; Bruehs, W. E. A Comparison of Reverse Projection and Laser Scanning Photogrammetry. J. For. Ident. 2018, 68 (2), 281-292.

Latent Image Transferred from Banknote

Author(s): Dove, Aaron
Type: Case Report
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 013
Abstract: An unlikely transfer of detail, initially thought to be friction ridges, was found on the inside of a plastic bag after processing the bag with cyanoacrylate fumes. Upon further examination, it was instead determined to be the partial image of Queen Elizabeth II from a Canadian $20 Frontier series polymer banknote.

Artifacts Caused by Livescan Affect a Latent Print Comparison: An Actual Case

Author(s): Giuliano, Andrea
Type: Case Report
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 020
Abstract: Occasionally, livescan devices produce images with artifacts that could later affect the comparison with a latent print. This issue may arise in court. The case presented in this paper reaffirms that the quality of known prints stored in a database remains a critical subject.

Examining the Effectiveness of Processing Fired Cartridge Cases for Latent Evidence

Author(s): Johnson, Stacey
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 027
Abstract: It is reasonable to assume that when an individual loads an unfired round into a weapon, latent print evidence and touch DNA evidence may be deposited on the round. One agency that Raleigh/ Wake City-County Bureau of Identification serves had shared information that it felt it had more success with pursuing touch DNA extraction from fired cartridge cases than from processing for latent print evidence. Latent prints were deliberately placed on a sample of unfired rounds. Another sample of unfired rounds was handled naturally prior to being fired. All of the fired cartridge cases were processed with cyanoacrylate and rhodamine 6G dye stain. Minimal ridge detail was observed on the deliberately handled cartridge cases, but the latent detail was determined to be not of value for identification. Latent detail was not observed on any of the naturally handled fired cartridge cases. The conclusion that was reached was that there may be better methods of collecting identifiable evidence from fired cartridge cases, including touch DNA.

Performance Review of the FF-1.0 Forensic Filter and the Expose Curved Barrier Filter by Arrowhead Forensics

Author(s): Sorum, Elisha D.
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 035
Abstract: The documentation of fluorescent fingerprints is commonly accomplished by emitting a specific wavelength of light via an alternate light source onto the substrate then photographing the results with an orange barrier filter attached to a camera lens and adjusting camera settings for the optimal possible contrast. However, many substrates may f luoresce at similar wavelengths as the latent prints, causing the latent prints to be weak or obscured. Having a choice between the standard orange barrier filter, the new FF-1.0 Forensic Filter, and the new Expose Curved Barrier Filter, or a combination thereof, will allow additional contrast of fluorescent latent prints by blocking the inherent fluorescence in certain substrates that may fluoresce at similar wavelengths as the latent fingerprints.

The Effect of Household Cleaning Agents on Blood and the Suitability for Screening Using the Phenolphthalein Test

Author(s): Signaevsky, Masha
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 049
Abstract: The phenolphthalein test is used in many forensic laboratories to presumptively reveal the presence of blood on an item of evidence. The mechanism of this test uses phenolphthalin, a chemical indicator, followed by hydrogen peroxide, an oxidizer, to detect the hemoglobin protein. The resulting pink color is attributed to the presence of blood; however, it may also be indicative of a chemical compound that has had an oxidative interaction with the indicator compound. At a bloody crime scene, it is common to expect an attempted clean-up using various cleaning agents, many of which have oxidizing capability. For this experiment, 40 cleaning products were tested with fresh blood on sterile swabs and on filter paper to determine their effect on the phenolphthalein test and vice versa. Of the 40 products, four were found to show a false positive result or an abnormality. These inconsistencies are attributable to the ingredients found in the four products and their chemical or oxidizing properties. Recognizing the characteristics of the irregular results can be of great help during testing in the laboratory.

Review of Several False Positive Error Rate Estimates for Latent Fingerprint Examination Proposed Based on the 2014 Miami-Dade Police Department Study

Author(s): Ausdemore, Madeline A.; Hendricks, Jessie H.; Neumann, Cedric
Type: Article
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 059
Abstract: In 2014, the Miami-Dade Police Department (MDPD) Forensic Services Bureau conducted research to study the false positive error rate (FPR) associated with latent fingerprint examination. They report that approximately 3.0% of latent fingerprint examinations result in a false positive conclusion. In their 2016 report, the Presidents Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) advise that this estimate of the FPR be used to inform jurors that errors occur at a detectible rate in fingerprint estimation and declare that false positive conclusions may occur as often as 1 in 18 cases. In this paper, we review the MDPD study and design a simulation study to model the behavior of the participants in the MDPD study. We use our model to simulate the number of erroneous identifications that occur under any assumed FPR and compare the results to the actual number of erroneous identifications observed in the MDPD study. We conduct experiments associated with the error rates proposed by the MDPD and the Organization of Scientific Area Committees Friction Ridge subcommittee. We note that the results of these experiments indicate that none of the proposed FPRs are reasonable estimates of the true FPR associated with the MDPD study. We propose two solutions based on a Bayesian analysis of the data, each resulting in two separate FPRs. Our solutions are comparable to the estimates offered by the Noblis black-box study.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2019, Volume 69, Issue 1, Page 124
Abstract: Funny finds from all over in their own words.

JFI Abstracts from 2018

Issue 4: October-December 2018

Two Cases of Dendrochronology Used to Corroborate a Forensic Postmortem Interval

Author(s): Pokines, James T.
Type: Case Report
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 457
Abstract:This report details two cases where the dendrochronology of tree roots was used in Massachusetts to provide a minimum postmortem interval (PMI) for a set of buried human remains. In both cases, the tree ring counts corroborated witness testimony regarding the approximate age of the burials; one analysis indicated a minimum of 27 years since burial, and the other indicated a minimum of 14.5 years since burial. Tree ring dating can fill an important role in minimum PMI estimation over intervals longer than can be covered by forensic entomology or other aspects of decompositional state, and tree root samples should be collected wherever they have a chance of aiding PMI estimation.

Photo Response Nonuniformity (PRNU) Meets Daubert Standards

Author(s): MacKenzie, Aislynn; Bruehs, Walter E.
Type: Case Report
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 467
Abstract: During United States of America v Nathan Allen Railey, photo response nonuniformity (PRNU) was used to identify a camera. This identification was challenged in an admissibility hearing to verify that the technology met the Daubert standard, setting a precedent for its use in future forensic examinations.

A New Method for Documenting Hertzian Fractures in Glass Windows

Author(s): Horn, Brent A.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 473
Abstract: Hertzian fractures, or cone fractures, caused by bullet perforations in glass windows can be useful in shooting incident reconstruction. However, they are difficult to photograph because of the transparent nature of glass. Standard glass documentation photographs prohibit determination of the deflection direction of light rays off fracture features, thus creating difficulty in determining the cone-bearing surface of the Hertzian fracture. This article presents a new method for photographing these fractures on various glass materials. Surface reflection photography (SRP) documents the contour-dependent nature of the surface and fracture, allowing the shooting reconstructionist to determine the bevel-bearing surface of the glass from the collected images without direct observation of the glass material. This method is applicable for annealed, tempered, laminated, and coated glass materials with both light and dark backgrounds.

Efficiency Assessment of Luminol-Based Formulations Using Bloodstains and Grayscale Intensity

Author(s): Carlier, Valentin; Bcue, Andy; Delemont, Olivier
Type: Article
Published: Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 490
Abstract: Luminol is often used to detect latent bloodstains at crime scenes. Several formulations of luminol-based solutions are available. These formulations must be compared and assessed for their efficiency for use at crime scenes. Most studies consider spectrometric measurements, where the reaction is triggered and monitored in spectrometric cells. In spectrometric cells, the blood is liquid, and the luminol ismixed with the blood, not sprayed onto it. Conclusions made from spectrometric measurements may not be accurately transposed to the situations of luminescence encountered under crime scene conditions because the testing conditions do not replicate the crime scene. This study consequently proposes a photographic-based method for measuring the chemiluminescence from bloodstains sprayed with luminol. The photographs that were made during the current experiments were converted into grayscale to provide objective values of the intensity of the chemiluminescence, which was recorded every 5 seconds during a period of 10 minutes. This photographic protocol was used to record both the regular luminol solution and also the luminol-f luorescein mixture. Results showed that the proposed method can objectively quantify the chemiluminescence intensity. Furthermore, contrary to what previous research that was based on spectrometric laboratory measurements indicated, the luminol-fluorescein mixture was not more efficient than a regular luminol solution. Differences may be explained by the measurement strategy (spectrometric measurement versus photographic recording), the proposed approach being more representative of the way luminol enhances bloodstains at crime scenes.

Latent Blood Detection and STR Analysis of Samples Collected from an American Civil War Field Hospital

Author(s): Jones, Kristin N.; McClintock, J. Thomas
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 509
Abstract: DNA analysis has recently been used to investigate samples of historical significance. During the last battle of the American Civil War (Sailors Creek Battlefield, Rice, VA), the Hillsman House served as a field hospital for wounded soldiers, treating more than 500 Union and Confederate soldiers. The presumed bloodstains on the floor under the single surgical table and two post-surgical beds provide evidence of the vast number of soldiers treated. These presumed bloodstains were collected and analyzed using various presumptive blood tests (luminol, phenolphthalein, leucomalachite green, and Rapid Stain Identification of Human Blood). To examine the genomic profiles, DNA was isolated from the collected samples, quantitated, amplified, and subjected to capillary electrophoresis. The generation of partial and complete DNA profiles confirmed the presence of human DNA, as well as the ability of DNA profiling to confirm historical accounts of soldiers being treated in a field hospital from a battle fought more than 150 years ago.

An Investigation into the Effect of Weight on Angle and Base of Gait

Author(s): Anness, R.; Curran, M. J.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 524
Abstract: The aim of this study was to evaluate changes in angle and base of gait when a person carries weight. This was undertaken using a sample of 15 participants. Wearing their own footwear, participants walked across a surface dusted with talcum powder and onto a long length of black paper to record their angle and base of gait. Participants did this several times, carrying a variety of weights up to 15 kg. The results indicated that when participants carried a 15 kg weight to the front of their body, the base of gait increased, and the left (nondominant) foot abducted more than the right. When they carried a 15 kg weight to the left side of the body, the base of gait decreased, and the left (nondominant) foot abducted excessively and the right foot marginally.

The Effect of Cyanoacrylate Fuming on Subsequent Protein Stain Enhancement of Fingermarks in Blood

Author(s): Mutter, Nicole; Deacon, Paul; Farrugia, Kevin J.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 545
Abstract: This study investigates the effect of cyanoacrylate (CA) fuming, at atmospheric and vacuum conditions, on subsequent protein stain (acid violet 17) enhancement of fingermarks in blood. Fingermark depletions in blood were deposited on three nonporous surfaces (e.g., plastic bag) and aged for a set period of time (up to 28 days) before enhancement with the water-ethanol-acetic acid and methanol formulations of acid violet 17 (AV17). All trials were carried out in duplicate. One depletion was pre-treated with CA fuming followed by the enhancement technique and the other depletion was treated with only the enhancement technique (control).As expected, atmospheric CA fuming hindered the subsequent enhancement of blood with the AV17 water-ethanol-acetic acid formulation but not the methanol formulation. The same observations were also recorded under vacuum CA fuming conditions. Preliminary work with vacuum metal deposition did not hinder subsequent AV17 protein stain enhancement with either formulation.

Longevity of Tween 20-Based PhysicalDeveloper

Author(s): Korzeniewski, Pawel; Svensson, Maria
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 557
Abstract: Physical developer (PD) based on Tween 20 can reportedly remain useful for weeks or even months, whereas PD based onSynperonic N only remains useful for days. We performed a limited longevity study on PD based on Tween 20 in which the reagent, once mixed, was tested weekly for 16 weeks. The solution remained useful for approximately 9 weeks, after which a development time set to 20 minutes appeared too short. At 9 weeks, the solution also showed marked labware staining, and a number of small beads of metallic silver appeared in the solution. Therefore, it appears that 2 months is a reasonable shelf-life for Tween 20-based PD.

Follow-up: Fingermark Development on Fired Cartridge Cases through the Electrodeposition of Gun Blue

Author(s): Dove, Aaron
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 567
Abstract: A previous study by Dove demonstrated that adding an electric charge to the treatment of brass cartridges by gun blue improves the contrast and quality of the resulting fingerprint development, with the results surpassing both the passive deposition of gun blue and the sequential cyanoacrylate fumingbrilliant yellow 40 technique. This follow-up study compares electrodepostion of gun blue to a current standard benchmark (palladium deposition) on fired cartridges. This study demonstrates that the electrodeposition of gun blue results in better quality friction ridge development compared to palladium deposition on laboratory samples. It does not, however, provide a solution to the deleterious effects the discharge of the bullet has on the fingermarks.

Latent Print Processing of Glassine Stamp Bags Containing Suspected Heroin: The Search for an Efficient and Safe Method

Author(s): Barnes, Brittany; Clark, Jason; Kadane, Joseph; Priestley, Marla; Spencer, Neil; Tator, Deborah; Wauthier, Denielle; Yohannan, Joshua
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 588
Abstract: A three-part study was designed to find the safest and most efficient method of processing glassine stamp bags containing suspected heroin while preserving the qualitative properties of the substance. Gravimetric analysis was also conducted to determine whether selected processing methods add weight to clean stamp bags. Qualitatively, the processing methods chosen for this study did not eliminate heroin from the samples. Results of a blind evaluation of developed latent prints indicate that under the controlled conditions of this study, magnetic powdering yielded the most of value latent fingerprints. However, because previous research has shown that magnetic powder is most effective a short time after fingerprint deposition (which was the case in this study), this conclusion should be regarded as tentative until longer times between deposition and recovery are studied. Gravimetrically, the processing methods used in this study add an amount of weight to the bags that is within the uncertainty of measurement for this laboratory.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 4, Page 612
Abstract: Funny finds from all over in their own words.

 

Issue 3: July-September 2018

Assessment of Friction Ridge Skin and Scars with a Focus on Latent Print Examination

Author(s): Schreel, Maralena; Stonehouse, April; Torres, Anne
Type: Correction
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Page 297
Abstract: On page 69 of the January-March 2018 issue of the Journal of Forensic Identification (volume 68, issue 1), the wrong chart was included as Figure 13. The correct figure is shown below. The editor apologizes to both the author and the JFI readers.

Expert Fingerprint Testimony Post-PCASTA Canadian Case Study

Author(s): Wilkinson, Della; Richard, David; Hockey, Daniel
Type: Case Report
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 299-331
Abstract: Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) expert testimony on fingerprint impression evidence was challenged by defense counsel, who called Dr. Simon Cole as an expert witness in the retrial of Timothy Bornyk, who was charged with a residential break and enter. The charge was based on a single fingerprint that was recovered from the crime scene. At the original trial, Justice Funt acquitted the accused, citing reports that were critical of fingerprint practices and perceived troubling aspects of the fingerprint testimony. The Crowns appeal was allowed because the trial judge had relied upon independently researched literature that was not properly tested in evidence, and he conducted an unguided fingerprint comparison.
For the retrial, the RCMP recommended that scientific studies and ongoing standards development work in the fingerprint community since the National Academies of Science (NAS) report should be presented to the court.
The Crowns strategy changed. First, the fingerprint examiner described RCMP policy on proficiency tests, use of the Scientific Working Group on Friction Ridge Analysis, Study and Technology (SWGFAST) Quality Table and Sufficiency Graph to assess quality and quantity of the minutiae in the latent print, erroneous identifications, and error rate studies. Second, key scientific publications and international best practices were introduced to the court. Finally, the verifier testified. Ten days later, Mr. Bornyk was found guilty.
This article summarizes the trials, the impact of the Presidents Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) report Forensic Science in Criminal Courts: Ensuring Scientific Validity of Feature-Comparison Methods on expert testimony, and provides an explanation of an incorrect error rate reproduced by PCAST. As the RCMP learn from this court challenge, potential future changes to RCMP research, policy, and training are discussed.

Frequency of Insufficient Knowns in Comparison and Processing Cases

Author(s): Cavazos, Christopher
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 333-340
Abstract: This project was designed to calculate the frequency of insufficient known inked impressions in comparison and processing cases with at least one identifiable latent fingerprint. Insufficient known inked impressions are described as having poor quality, lacking the area needed to conduct a conclusive comparison, or a combination of the two. This study analyzed 256 cases from the Western Regional North Carolina State Crime Laboratory from 2004 to 2009 and 460 cases from the Raleigh North Carolina State Crime Laboratory from 2013 to 2015, for a combined total of 716 cases. This study showed nearly 20% of all cases involved had insufficient known impressions. A lack of friction ridge information being recorded in the known impressions was the main contributor to the determination of insufficiency.

Comparison of the Quantity and Overall Quality of Trace DNA Evidence Collected from Substrates Found at Crime Scenes

Author(s): Hogan, Chad; Van Houten, Lora Bailey; Coticone, Sulekha
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 341-347
Abstract: The ability to recover high-quality trace DNA samples from crime scenes depends on the characteristics of the contributor, the surfaces, the environment, and the time until recovery. In this study, saliva samples were deposited on various surfaces, followed by periodic swabbing at timed intervals for 3 months. The results indicate that porous surfaces (e.g., brick) provide lower amounts and quality of DNA as compared with smooth surfaces (e.g., plastic, glass).

Impact of Anti-Fingerprint Coatings on the Detection of Fingermarks

Author(s): Forchelet, Sandra; Bcue, Andy
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 348-368
Abstract: This study discusses the deposition and behavior of fingermark residue (eccrine, sebum-rich, and natural) on anti-fingerprint (AFP) coatings as well as the impact of these coatings on conventional detection techniques (cyanoacrylate fuming, small particle reagent, vacuum metal deposition). The preliminary conclusions show that (1) AFP coatings do not prevent the deposition of secretion residue, (2) the amphiphobic properties of AFP coatings may benefit the preservation and observation of latent marks, (3) AFP coatings do not hinder the application of conventional detection techniques, and (4) the impact of AFP coatings on ridge clarity is overall positive or limited, with differences of behavior between plastic-based coatings (negative impact mostly) and glass-based ones (positive impact mostly).

Detection of Fingermarks from Post-Blast Debris: A Review

Author(s): Smyth, Alexander; Sims, Mark R.; Holt, John
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 369-378
Abstract: Fingermarks, an important area of forensic investigations, are generally believed to be destroyed during explosive events. Therefore, post-blast investigations are rarely centered around fingermark evidence recovery to identify a suspect. In-depth research into the recovery of fingermarks from post-blast scenes is lacking. Only five research attempts have been published to date. These five publications are reviewed here. By summarizing the research to date, future experimental work can be conducted to build upon this fledgling research area to the point where a repeatable and successful technique may be discovered.

Comparison of Latent Print Proficiency Tests with Latent Prints Obtained in Routine Casework Using Automated and Objective Quality Metrics

Author(s): Koertner, Anthony J.; Swofford, Henry J.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 379-388
Abstract: This study evaluates how well the quality of latent print proficiency test samples represent those encountered during routine casework and starts a conversation on what these data really mean. Currently, proficiency tests are designed to monitor the performance of laboratoriesfrom when the examiner receives the materials to when results are releasedto satisfy accreditation requirements and demonstrate the validity of the methods when applied to test samples representative of casework. In order to do this, the latent print samples are intended to mimic the quality or difficulty encountered during routine casework; however, there is a dearth of research to verify this claim. Subjective experience from the latent print community has been that proficiency tests offer higher quality and less complex examinations than those typically evaluated in routine casework. Sampling of latent fingerprints obtained from commercially available latent print proficiency tests and latent fingerprints obtained over the course of routine casework were collected and compared using objective latent print quality metrics. Results indicated that the quality levels of latent fingerprints from proficiency tests are generally higher quality, less complex, and do not represent the quality levels observed in routine casework.

Determination of Detection Sequence for Optimal Visualization of Blood Fingermarks on a Dark Surface

Author(s): Bouwmeester, Martine; Siem-Gorr, Shermayne
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 389-402
Abstract: This article is a follow-up to the study Comparison of the Reagents SPR-W and Acid Yellow 7 for the Visualization of Blood Marks on a Dark Surface. In the current studyzxc v, the sequential processing of cyanoacrylate with the reagents basic yellow 40 (also known as panacryl brilliant flavine) and small particle reagent white (SPR-W, also known as titanium dioxide) on blood fingermarks was investigated. Following the study of the sequential processing techniques, the use of a fixing agent before coloring and the DNA recovery rate were measured.
The single treatment with SPR-W on fingermarks with blood, without cyanoacrylate and basic yellow, gave the best results in terms of visibility of the marks.
DNA recovery was more successful when the blood marks were first treated with cyanoacrylate. The first blood fingermark of the depletion series gave the best DNA result. Fresh fingermarks of up to a week, which were fixed with ethanol right before coloring with SPR-W, gave a slightly better DNA result.

Assessing the Appearance of Latent Print Distortion on Absorbent and Nonabsorbent Substrates

Author(s): Tate, David; Anderson, Elizabeth; Eller, Jesse
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 403-420
Abstract: Lateral movement, or shearing stress, may occur in a latent print. In this study, we examined lateral movement of a finger on copier paper (absorbent substrate) and lateral movement of a finger on porcelain tile (nonabsorbent substrate) to determine whether there were any observable differences in the appearance of impressions deposited in a specifically controlled direction (laterally). An attempt was made to control the matrix volume, duration of contact, and the absorption properties of the substrate for all trials. Results showed that visual clues (e.g., the intensity of the impression at the start of movement compared to the intensity of the impression at the end of movement, and the presence of a corona at the ending impression) could assist in determining directionality of finger movement on the absorbent substrate.

Preliminary Studies into the Secondary Transfer of Undeveloped Latent Fingermarks Between Surfaces

Author(s): Jabbal, Randeep S.; Boseley, Rhiannon E.; Lewis, Simon W.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 421-437
Abstract: This study investigates the conditions under which undeveloped fingermarks will transfer between surfaces that have come into contact. Latent fingermarks were deposited on a glass surface, which was brought into contact with paper surfaces for varying periods of time and pressure. Subsequently, the paper was treated with a variety of development procedures including 1,2-indanedione-zinc, ninhydrin, Oil red O, aqueous Nile blue, and SMD II. 1,2-Indanedione-zinc was successful at detecting transferred fingermarks, with good contrast and ridge definition, observed when fresh fingermarks were transferred by contact with the secondary surface for a minimum of 24 hours under a 5.00 kg pressure. The high degree of clarity and contrast of the developed transferred fingermark made it difficult to differentiate as a secondary mark. Transferred marks can only be recognized as a mirror image when compared to a mark directly deposited from an individual.

Using Luminol to Detect Bloodstains Exposed to Fire, Heat, and Soot on Multiple Surfaces

Author(s): Akemann, Emma; Bushong, Lee C.; Jones, Ward M.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Pages 438-453
Abstract: This article investigates the ability of luminol to detect bloodstains that have been exposed to fire, heat, soot, and water. Blood applied to drywall, appliance sheet metal, glazed tile, carpet, and wood was exposed to fire, followed by typical firefighter extinguishment. The results show that bloodstains on some surfaces that have been exposed to heat, fire, soot, or water may produce false negatives when tested with luminol.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 3, Page 456
Abstract: Funny finds from all over in their own words.

 

Issue 2: April-June 2018

Laterally Reversed Latent Prints Developed Using 1,2-Indanedione

Author(s): Brazelle, Shelly; Inlow, Vici; Leitner, Mary Lou
Type: Case Report
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 161-170
Abstract: Laterally reversed latent prints that have been attributed to transfer from one surface to a second surface have been reported in cases where different processing techniques have been used on bags, books, and adhesive surfaces. Three cases demonstrating the existence of laterally reversed latent prints when no surface transfer has occurred are presented. Each case of a laterally reversed latent print was developed with the chemical reagent 1,2-indanedione. The increased use of 1,2-indanedione and the ability to develop laterally reversed latent prints demonstrate the need to address issues regarding recognition, documentation, reporting, and policy procedures.

Use of Gelatin Lifters and Episcopic Coaxial Illumination for the Recovery and Imaging of Latent Fingermarks from Various Surfaces

Author(s): Attard, Chantelle; Lennard, Chris
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 171-185
Abstract: A study was conducted to assess the effectiveness of gelatin lifters as a method of latent fingermark recovery. Such a capability may be important in covert operations where rapid, nondestructive techniques need to be applied. A preliminary trial was conducted to determine the best surface types for fingermark recovery using black gelatin lifts, with the resulting lifted impressions imaged using an optical method referred to as episcopic coaxial illumination (ECI). As expected, it was found that fresh, sebum-rich fingermarks on smooth, nonporous surfaces produced the best results. A more extensive study was then conducted using natural fingermarks from multiple donors and fingermarks aged for periods up to six weeks. Both black and white gelatin lifters were assessed, as well as the impact of reattaching the protective plastic film provided to cover the lifted impressions. The best results were obtained using black lifters applied to nonporous surfaces that contained sebum-rich, relatively fresh impressions (i.e., aged for a short period of time). Lifts that were left uncovered prior to ECI imaging also resulted in higher quality fingermarks. The use of a commercially available ECI accessory was found to be a cost-effective method for the recording of lifted impressions.

Variability of Class Characteristics Observed in Die Cut Outsoles Composed of Both Rubber and Textile Materials

Author(s): Gokool, Vidia A.; John, Jeremy A.; Koertner, Anthony J.
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 187-206
Abstract: This study examines the variability of certain manufactured features of unworn footwear outsoles that relate to their textile coverings. The manufacturing process that is used in producing the Sanuk Vagabond and Toms Classic involves die-cutting a sheet stock, which is composed of a mixed ethylene vinyl acetate and rubber compound with a textile layer faceted on top. The addition of the textile layer during the molding process reduces the amount of exposed mixed-rubber material to a dotted pattern of exposed area, thus creating a new feature that is variable to the class characteristics on the outsole. This manufacturing process introduces variance in outsole features from shoe to shoe. Measurements of the variabilities yielded statistical data that support the use of textile-induced outsole features in relation to outsole-imbedded features as an additional highly discriminating characteristic to be considered in footwear comparison examinations.

A Comparison of Hydrophobic Barriers for Casting Footwear Impressions in Water-Soluble Food Products

Author(s): Sabolich, Adam R.
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 207-221
Abstract: Eight different products were tested to determine a hydrophobic barrier that could best preserve a footwear impression in water-soluble food products. A control test was performed with no product used between the water-soluble food product and the casting product. Because many of the products sufficiently preserved the more pronounced three-dimensional features, a set of minor and individual features were isolated to gauge the efficacy of each product. The results were varied. Some products produced an even worse cast than the control; others preserved only the major features. The best results were obtained using the sequential treatment of Krylon Colormaster Crystal Clear Gloss Spray Acrylic -> Arrid XX Ultra Clear Aerosol Spray Antiperspirant and Deodorant -> Snow Print Wax.

Laser Bullet Trajectory Photography

Author(s): Lemasters, Timothy; Johnson, Daniel; Miller Brian
Type: Technical Note
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 223-233
Abstract: The ability to capture laser bullet trajectory in daylight conditions is important. Most crime scene investigator trajectory kits do not include the necessary equipment for all conditions and should be augmented with higher powered laser pointers and neutral density filters. This technical note describes a method for consistent capturing of laser trajectory beams during daylight conditions.

Estimating Stature from the Measurements of Upper Limbs in the Indo-Mauritian Population

Author(s): Agnihotri, Arun Kumar; Tangman, Yannick
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 234-255
Abstract: The aim of this study was to predict stature in the Indo-Mauritian population, when that the sex of the individual was unknown. Measurements [height (stature), upper limb length, upper arm length, forearm length, hand length, and the length of the second to the fifth fingers] of 200 young and healthy students (100 male and 100 females), aged 19 25, were taken using standard anthropometric instruments. A significant relationship was found between the stature and upper limb dimensions (adjusted R2 ranged from 67.63% to 80.91%), with the highest linear association observed for the upper right limb. The standard error of the estimate for stature prediction ranged from 3.70 cm to 5.15 cm for both sexes. Multiple linear regression equations using sex as a dummy variable gave better results than simple linear regression equations. Our regression models were sufficiently validated and highly efficient.

Assessing Phosphomolybdic Acid as a Fingermark Enhancement Reagent

Author(s): Davis, Lloyd W.L.; Bleay, Stephen M.; Kelly, Paul F.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 257-280
Abstract: The efficacy of an ethanolic solution of phosphomolybdic acid (PMA) was investigated as a latent fingermark visualization reagent, primarily on porous substrates. After treating samples and exposing them to ultraviolet radiation, the PMA solution was shown to develop fingermarks of high quality. Unlike the common amino acid reagents that are used for the development of fingermarks on porous substrates (e.g., ninhydrin and 1,8 diazafluoren-9-one), PMA stains a range of other compounds that are found in fingermark deposits, including lipids. The lysochrome diazo dye Oil Red O (ORO) was used for comparative purposes because of its application in staining some of the same components of fingermark residues for which PMA would be proposed. Initial results indicate that PMA is comparable to ORO at developing fingermarks on porous surfaces and may also have applications on nonporous surfaces.

A Comparison of Reverse Projection and Laser Scanning Photogrammetry

Author(s): Meline, Kimberly A.; Bruehs, Walter E.
Type: Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Pages 281-292
Abstract: Reverse projection photogrammetry has long been the standard by which height determination examinations have been conducted from security camera imagery. The uncertainty associated with this method is well understood. Laser scanning for this same use is gaining traction in the field of forensic video analysis as an alternative methodology. Laser scanning offers highly accurate measurements of the scene without the burden of placing a camera back into the same position it was in at the time of the crime. Additionally, the laser scanning methodology is not dependent on recreating the digital video recorders output aspect ratio, which is dependent on the recording device. An experiment was conducted to compare the accuracy of measurements that were obtained through both methods. Both methods yielded similar results, indicating further study should be conducted into laser scanning to determine how the error associated with laser scanning changes with different variables (e.g., the resolution of the imagery, distance from the camera, and the height of the camera). Further study is needed to define whether the technique passes thresholds that are suitable for court admittance.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: Back to Basics
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 2, Page 296
Abstract: The most interesting pattern type on this hand is the tented arch in the left index finger. It is a classic tented arch of the up-thrust type. It is the bonus and not the main focus of this issue.

 

Issue 1: January-March 2018

Detection and Identification of a Latent Palmprint on a Cartridge

Author(s): Waldron, Michelle E.; Walls, Adrianne
Type: : Correction
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Page 001
Abstract: On page 479 of the OctoberDecember 2017 issue of the Journal of Forensic Identification (volume 67, issue 4), the case report indicated that "of 2,727 cartridges that were processed, no latent prints that were suitable for comparison purposes were developed [1]." Although it is true that 2,727 unfired cartridges were processed in that study with no successes, an additional 259 discharged cartridges were also processed, with 1 success. (Read the article here)

A Case Report: The Analysis of Patent Prints Identified as Forgeries

Author(s): Sellenraad, Ashley
Type: : Case Report
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 003-009
Abstract: During the analysis of this case, three patent fingerprints on three separate checks were identified as being forgeries. A small experiment using friction ridge skin and black printers ink was conducted. The results of this experiment verified that the pliability of skin would not allow for an exact replication of a print, particularly around the edges, which was observed in the patent prints that were submitted in this case. It was determined that a stamp had been used as the method for depositing the patent prints on the checks.

Silver Nitrate Grade and Its Effect on Physical Developer Performance-- A Validation Study

Author(s): Coppes, Allison; Ramotowski, Robert S.; Jones, Brian A.; Manna, Michael E.; Chervinsky, Esther V.; Smith, Kim D.
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 011-027
Abstract: Silver nitrate is a critical component of the physical developer (PD) reagent. Significant increases in the cost of silver nitrate in recent years have caused the United States Secret Services Forensic Laboratory to look for a more economical way to produce physical developer. One possible solution to this dilemma is to use a lower grade of silver nitrate, which typically has a lower cost. This study compared the quality of fingerprints produced on various paper substrates by three physical developer working solutions, each prepared using either the American Chemical Society (ACS), U.S. Pharmacopeia (USP), or technical grade of silver nitrate. It was determined that the less pure grades of silver nitrate produced approximately the same quality of fingerprints as the ACS grade, which is currently used in the authors laboratory for making PD working solutions. In the experiments comparing PD prepared using the ACS and USP grades of silver nitrate, the ACS grade was superior only 5% of the time, whereas the USP grade was chosen 27% of the time. In the experiments comparing PD prepared using the ACS and technical grades of silver nitrate, the ACS grade was superior only 10% of the time, whereas the technical grade was selected 17% of the time. For the majority of the sample comparisons, no difference in fingerprint quality was observed. The overall conclusion was that either USP or technical grade silver nitrate can be used in place of the current, and more expensive, ACS grade of silver nitrate.

Lay Understanding of "Identification": How Jurors Interpret Forensic Identification Testimony

Author(s): Swofford, H.J.; Cino, J.G.
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 029-041
Abstract: In recent years there have been several discussions amongst forensic science policy makers, forensic practitioners, legal practitioners, and academia regarding the most appropriate means of expressing forensic conclusions, especially pertaining to source associations in the pattern evidence domains, to ensure proper articulation of the weight of the evidence to the fact finder. Central to these discussions is the use of the words "identification" or "individualization" to report positive associations between an evidence sample and a known sourceoften used to express the opinion that the two samples "were made by the same source". Proponents argue that the terms are appropriate provided that they are properly defined and caveated to be an expression of an opinion. Critics argue that the terms are inappropriate because they imply a weight of evidence that has not yet been empirically demonstrated and, given the historical use of the terms, simply avoiding the added phrase "to the exclusion of all others" is insufficient. An underlying question at the heart of this discussion, then, is how lay persons interpret such testimony. After polling 300 lay persons, we found that approximately 71% of potential jurors may be expected to interpret expert testimony containing the word "identification" (or "identified") to imply a single source attribution "to the exclusion of all others". The intent of this study is to provide preliminary data to inform the forensic science community on how the term "identification" may be interpreted by laypersons when used in the context of expert testimony and technical reports.

Assessment of Friction Ridge Skin and Scars with a Focus on Latent Print Examination

Author(s): Schreel, Maralena; Stonehouse, April; Torres, Anne
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 043-075
Abstract: A questionnaire was distributed to establish baseline knowledge on the use of scarred friction ridges in the latent print discipline. Questions were designed to evaluate the utilization and weight of scar features in the decision-making process and to assess the value of scars in a latent comparison. Twenty-nine latent print examiners participated in the 94-question survey. The results of this questionnaire showed that despite the lack of literature and formalized training, participants (1) were able to use their experience to make comparative decisions, including identifications, that were based on scar features; (2) were consistent in recognizing and assigning weight to scars; and (3) were able to use scars, or the absence of them, to substantiate their decisions.

Hand Determination of Whorl Patterns Using Axis Slant

Author(s): Brazelle, Mack; Brazelle, Shelly
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 077-086
Abstract: This study examines the use of whorl slant in hand determination through whorl axis analysis. Two certified latent print examiners determined the whorl axis for 550 whorls. They found a higher percentage of right slant whorls in the right hand (92.7% and 93.8%) and a higher percentage of left slant whorls in the left hand (91.0% and 91.2%). A small percentage of whorls absent of any axis were reported in both hands. Interestingly, a higher percentage of right slant whorls were present in the left index finger, and a higher percentage of left slant whorls were present in the right index finger. Applying the chi-square test to overall whorl slant data from each hand demonstrated that using the whorl axis to determine hand orientation is statistically significant.

Differential Diagnosis of the Taphonomic Histories of Common Types of Forensic Osseous Remains

Author(s): Pokines, James T.
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 087-145
Abstract: How a set of osseous remains under forensic anthropological examination is analyzed and processed and reaches its ultimate disposition is largely guided by the taphonomic source of the remains, including environmental and temporal factors. The environment from which the remains came, whether largely natural or artificial, alters the remains in ways that allow for the determination of their origin and subsequent taphonomic histories. Remains are also subject to temporal jurisdiction, in that older remains may be forwarded to other agencies, including state archaeological offices, for final disposition. The present research examines and compares the taphonomic alterations that are formed on bones from multiple sources that are commonly received in medical examiner settings: terrestrial, marine, cemetery, trophy, and former anatomical teaching specimens. Each of these sources has unique taphonomic alterations associated with it, and careful examination can elucidate the history of a set of remains, even where their environment has changed, including repurposing for ritual or other uses.

Can Intentionally Compacting a Clandestine Grave Make it More Difficult to Detect with a Soil Probe?

Author(s): Dubsky, Alexandre; Christensen, Angi M.
Type: : Article
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Pages 147-156
Abstract: A soil probe is an economical and efficient tool for locating clandestine graves, allowing the user to identify differences in relative soil compaction that may indicate a disturbance such as a grave. Partly because of popular portrayals of crime investigations in the media, perpetrators may modify their criminal practices to avoid detection. One conceivable approach would be for a perpetrator to intentionally re-compact a grave site after burying a body in an attempt to hinder the ability of investigators to locate the grave using methods based on relative soil compaction. Here we test the use of a tamper tool to compact disturbed soil and investigate whether such efforts are likely to result in evading detection. Undisturbed, normally filled, and intentionally compacted soil sites were probed weekly using a weighted soil probe, and probe depths were compared. Results show that although probe depths for the soil compacted with a tamper tool were less than those for the normally filled sites (p < 0.001), they were still significantly greater (p < 0.001) < 0.001) than those for the undisturbed soil, suggesting that such graves would still be detected by using a soil probe.

Back to Basics

Author(s): Siegel, Sandy
Type: : Back to Basics
Published: 2018, Volume 68, Issue 1, Page 160
Abstract: Past QUIPs have featured examples of syndactyly (webbed fingers), polydactyly (extra digits), and even an exemplar of double thumbs with a great scorpion tattoo. The prints above are examples of ectrodactyly, which is a congenital lack of one or more digits.